Hey everyone, how's it going? I'm doing pretty well for a hot and humid Monday. This weekend was San Diego Comic-Con, THE comic book and pop culture convention of the year. Over the weekend we got news from the Star Trek Universe, including two teasers, and that's what I wanna talk about today, along with the state of Star Trek in this year. Engage!
When Star Trek: Starfleet Academy was first announced back in 2018, I was really excited because Josh Schwartz and Stephanie Savage were going to be the showrunners. Having been a big fan of The O.C. in the 2000s and Marvel's Runaways in the 2010s, I knew that any teen drama Star Trek series would be in good hands with them in charge. However, when it was announced in 2023 that Schwartz and Savage had moved on and Starfleet Academy would have Alex Kurtzman and Noga Landau as showrunners instead, I was much more on the fence. I'm not against Kurtzman as the showrunner of a Star Trek show. However teen dramas, and shows involving a main cast of teenage characters in general, are very hard to do and there have been very few of them in the last twenty years that have actually been good. And I didn't know if Kurtzman would be able to manage that challenge.
Starfleet Academy has actually been the target for a Star Trek series as far back as 1986, when Paramount was looking to bring Star Trek back to television prior to the release of Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home. According to various books and magazine articles (they're all mentioned in the "Undeveloped Star Trek Projects" article on Memory Alpha, the Star Trek Wiki), before Gene Roddenberry was brought in to do the show that became TNG, one show that was in development was a show set at Starfleet Academy, and another, by Sam and Greg Strangis, was to have a group of cadets running a new Starship Enterprise. Harve Bennett who produced four Star Trek films that came out between 1982 and 1989, had also planned to do a movie for the 25th anniversary of the franchise that would have Kirk and the original crew at Starfleet Academy with a wraparound that would have Shatner, Nimoy, and Kelley return as Kirk, Spock, and McCoy. That eventually became Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, without Bennett.
There have also been numerous episodes, books, and comics that were set at Starfleet Academy. Not to mention we had Starfleet cadets on the Enterprise in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. So the idea of a Starfleet Academy focused story has been around for close to forty-five years now.
I started to get excited for this new show when it was announced that Mary Wiseman would be appearing as Tilly, Tig Notaro would be part of the main cast as Jett Reno, and Robert Picardo would be reprising his role as the Doctor from Voyager. That was the hook for me since I'm such a huge fan of Star Trek: Voyager and I loved Reno and Tilly on Discovery.
Having said that though, after watching the teaser that we got over the weekend, I'm excited for the show because of its premise. The basic premise is that Starfleet is returning the academy to its traditional campus on Earth for the first time in 125 years and the cast of cadets we'll be introduced to will be the first to grace the hallowed grounds of Starfleet Academy. The grounds occupied by legends such as James T. Kirk, Kathryn Janeway, Benjamin Sisko, Christopher Pike and their crews. So I am really excited to see what possibilities the show will present us. Not to mention tons of easter eggs and return of species such as a Jem'Hadar, who is actually a female that is a Klingon-Jem'Hadar hybrid, as well as a Betazoid woman. Other than an appearance in the Lower Decks episode, "Empathological Fallacies", we haven't seen a Betazoid (that wasn't Deanna Troi or her and Riker's daughter, Kestra) in Star Trek since Ensign Jurot in "Counterpoint" from Voyager's fifth season, so it'll be interesting to see the Betazoids in the 32nd Century finally, as well as a Klingon, as we're gonna have a Klingon cadet.
I'm really excited for Starfleet Academy and I'm hoping it doesn't fall prey to the tropes and flaws of modern teen dramas. Or if it does, it's at the very least entertaining as it does so.
Now, Star Trek: Khan is a scripted podcast that will show how Khan and his followers survived on Ceti Alpha V between "Space Seed" and Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. I've gone on record before that I am not a fan of Khan and feel that he is an extremely overrated villain. That's still true today. However, I'm interested in this show because of its framing story, which has a journalist or historian trying to piece together Khan's time on Ceti Alpha V, following the events of Star Trek VI, with George Takei reprising his role as Captain Hikaru Sulu, and Tim Russ reprising his role as Tuvok. This is the younger, Ensign Tuvok though that served under Sulu onboard the Excelsior as was revealed in the Voyager episode, "Flashback" from the third season. So that's the part I'm intrigued by rather than Khan's story itself.
Personally, I feel that we don't need to know how Khan and his crew survived on Ceti Alpha V. It really doesn't matter because all that actually matters is that he survived long enough to be in The Wrath of Khan. But, if it has to be told, I'm glad it's being done as a podcast and it's being done the way it's being done, with the framing story. This was supposed to be a miniseries on Paramount+ but due to unknown circumstances, it was turned into a podcast. And this was long before Section 31 had come out, so I can't even begin to guess as to the reasons why this series was turned into Star Trek's first audio drama like the ones produced for Doctor Who. Which is interesting.
Before I go, I'd like to talk about the state of Star Trek as a whole in the year 2025. I've seen people online comparing the state of Star Trek today to the state of Star Trek when Enterprise ended back in 2005. There are some similarities. For example, as I talked about in the very first post on this blog, Star Trek Communicator ended publication shortly before Enterprise finished airing and the most recent Star Trek magazine, Star Trek Explorer, ended publication a few months ago, just after Lower Decks finished airing. Another example is that Rick Berman's contract with Paramount for Star Trek was ending in 2006, about a year after the Enterprise finale, and the end of Alex Kurtzman's contract with Paramount for Star Trek is ending next year, in 2026. However that's where the similarities end.
While there aren't as many Star Trek shows on the air this year as there have been in the last five years with Discovery, Picard, Lower Decks, and Prodigy having all finished production and finished airing, we still have Strange New Worlds for two and a half seasons, Starfleet Academy premiering early next year, and the potential for more Star Trek shows and movies is present as well. Also, the big reason we haven't heard about anything more for any future Star Trek shows or movies is that the acquisition of Paramount Global by Skydance Media hadn't been approved yet, so I think the people at Star Trek waited to announce further projects until that had been finalized and approved. According to Wikipedia, the merger is expected to close next week on August 7th.
We still have Tawny Newsome's Star Trek workplace sitcom supposedly still in development, though, again, because of the merger, we haven't heard anything official from Paramount about that show. And even though Strange New Worlds is ending, we still have Starfleet Academy on the air. Back in 2005 there were no Star Trek projects on the horizon as Enterprise had been canceled, and Paramount had also canceled Berman's plans for an 11th Star Trek feature film. The only real merger that was happening back then was between UPN and The WB in 2006, which dissolved both networks, leaving The CW in their wake. And being that any shows that had been on UPN prior to the merger, and had moved over to The CW for the 2006-2007 television season, were canceled by the end of that season, even if UPN hadn't canceled Enterprise in 2005, I doubt it would've lasted more than the five seasons it would've had if UPN hadn't canceled it when it did.
So Star Trek is in a very different place in 2025 than it was twenty years ago. I feel it's also in a much stronger place today than it was in 2005. Star Trek has always had low viewership since its inception back in 1966. In fact, it's never surpassed any of the most popular shows in the '90s. However, Star Trek fans have always been super passionate about their love for the franchise.
The fans are who have kept Star Trek alive for almost 59 years at this point. Even when the general audience hasn't supported the various TV shows and movies. In the '70s we wrote fan fiction, published fanzines, wrote technical manuals and compendiums about the original series. In the '80s we bought the novels and comics, and wondered how Spock might return from the dead in Star Trek III. In the '90s we watched TNG, DS9, and Voyager as they aired new episodes every week, watched the reruns of TOS multiple times, AND bought all the shows on VHS, even if we didn't get every single episode. In the 2000s we bought all the shows on DVD, watched Enterprise every week, and continued to buy the novels. And you know why? Because Star Trek fans, true Star Trek fans, love Star Trek in all of its incarnations.
Star Trek was never the highest rated show on TV. It was never the highest grossing movies of all time. We never cared though, because it was Star Trek. Whether a bald black man was blackmailing criminals to insure that the Romulans joined the war with the Dominion on the side of the Federation and Klingons, or a bald white dude was giving long speeches to his crew on the virtues of the Prime Directive, or a woman commanded a ship lost in the Delta Quadrant, or a Starfleet legend blew up his equally legendary ship to prevent the Klingons from capturing it, and because those same Klingons had just killed his son five minutes earlier. It was still Star Trek regardless.
Because of all of that, Star Trek will never truly die. Oh sure, it might go off the air for 12 to 17 years at a time, but it will never truly go away. The classic shows are still airing in reruns on broadcast television. They're all available on DVD and most of them are available on Blu-ray. We have hundreds of novels, comics, and video games. And while new fans aren't going to come from the general audience very often, they will, and have, come from the families who watched the shows together when they aired on TV, whether it was the '60s, the '80s, the '90s, the 2000s, or present day. They come from children being introduced to Star Trek through their parents, as I was. They might even come from the children who watched Nickelodeon one day and discovered Prodigy, even if their parents aren't Star Trek fans.
Star Trek is about hope, and the belief that Humanity will grow and evolve beyond the prejudice, hate, and greed that we experience in everyday life. It's about the fans who watch the show and say, "I want to make a difference for the better in this world I live in". It's about the people whose lives were changed by Star Trek. And, it's about that little boy who got to visit the set of TNG in January, 1993, as they filmed the sixth season episode, "Lessons", and the day of joy it brought him and his parents, at a time when they faced so much uncertainty. For that day that little boy could forget that he had disabilities as he got out of his wheelchair and sat in the captain's chair on the Bridge of his favourite starship (even though it was just a set from a TV show), pretend to fire phasers and photon torpedoes from Worf's tactical station, and pretend to set a course for the nearest starbase, maximum warp, because Captain Picard ordered him to, and be transported to a possible future where his disabilities wouldn't be so limiting.
Alright my friends, that's going to be it for me for today. I'll be back later this week for my next episode review for season 3 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, and then I'll also be over either on Josh's Geek Cave or The Star Wars Journal for another post on one or the other. Until then, have a great evening and I will talk to you all later. Live long and prosper!